Behavior traps answer one of the hardest questions in applied behavior analysis (ABA): how does a skill taught in a lesson keep going in real life, with real people, long after the lesson ends? This guide explains the term from its original sources, shows the classic studies, and walks through setting a trap in a classroom or at home.
What a behavior trap is
Donald Baer and Montrose Wolf described the idea in their 1970 chapter "The entry into natural communities of reinforcement." Their point was that "for some problems there exists already an effective community of fellow behavior modifiers, their programs well practiced, effective, and running, waiting only for an introduction to the subject" (Baer and Wolf, 1970, p. 320, as quoted in Kohler and Greenwood, 1986).
In a preschool, for example, that community is the other children. Their prompts, smiles and approval can occasion and reinforce a child's behavior with peers. Kohler and Greenwood describe Baer and Wolf's assertion that although a small number of responses might be needed to enter a trap, general changes across responses, settings and time follow once the trap is entered (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986).
"Natural" has a specific meaning here. Kohler and Greenwood use it for stimuli that fall outside the variables used to produce the first behavior change, and that are under the control of the peer group rather than the teacher or researcher. Their paper focuses on peers, but they note that the same analysis applies to other agents, such as parents, spouses and teachers, and to traps made up of nonsocial stimuli (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986).
Behavior trap examples from the research
Kohler and Greenwood reviewed the applied research since 1964 and cite several early studies where a small change seemed to be picked up and carried by the natural environment (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986):
- Allen and colleagues (1964) reinforced a girl's standing within three feet of another child; within six days she was consistently interacting with her peers.
- Buell and colleagues (1968) shaped a child's use of outdoor play equipment and found that her untrained social interactions with peers also increased.
- Hall and Broden (1967) used adult attention to change a child's social behavior; the improvements were still obvious six months later.
An illustration written for this guide: a student who loves a sport reads about their favorite players with a classmate who shares the interest. If the interesting information and the conversation keep the student reading as the teacher fades points, that is consistent with a behavior trap. Alber and Heward's (1996) article "GOTCHA!" gives 25 classroom traps of this kind, built on students' heroes, special interests and clubs, school and community resources, and even turning around annoying classroom behaviors (Alber and Heward, 1996). Our archive article on behavior traps by Amanda Fishley, MA, BCBA, walks through their steps with a baseball example.
Why behavior traps matter: generalization and maintenance
A skill that appears only with the person who taught it, or only while the rewards last, has not yet done its job. Stokes and Baer (1977) reviewed the generalization research and grouped it under nine headings; one of them is "Introduce to Natural Maintaining Contingencies," which is the behavior trap at work. Another, "Train and Hope," names the common habit of teaching and hoping the skill will transfer on its own.
In their 1986 paper, Kohler and Greenwood noted that few studies reported long-term follow-up. They cite a review of 146 studies in the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, Behavior Therapy and Behaviour Research and Therapy that found only 11% reported follow-up data collected six months or longer after treatment. They add that the shortage of data does not mean target behaviors are rarely trapped; it more likely means researchers are not assessing long-term maintenance (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986).
Traps work in both directions. Kohler and Greenwood describe a study in which girls in an institutional setting consistently delivered putative reinforcers for their peers' deviant behavior and aversive stimuli for following institutional rules. Natural contingencies can support problem behavior, and they call for a technology to reprogram traps that support problematic behaviors or fail to maintain the behaviors society considers important (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986).
How to set a behavior trap
These four steps follow from the sources above. Alber and Heward describe traps that lure a student into a "success circle" of increasing knowledge and skills (Alber and Heward, 1996); the early researchers Kohler and Greenwood cite recommended training only behaviors that would be maintained after the intervention ends, and examining which child behaviors reliably produce positive reactions from peers (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986).
- Find the bait. Start from what the learner already seeks out: a favorite topic, game, character or person. Watch what they choose during free time, and ask them and their family.
- Pick a skill the environment will reward. Choose a behavior that peers, family or daily routines will respond to without your help, such as asking to join a game the learner loves.
- Teach the way in. Teach an entry response the learner can already do or learn quickly that brings the learner into contact with that reinforcement. Prompt it, reinforce it, and set up the first few chances.
- Step back and watch. Fade your prompts and planned rewards, then keep taking data. If the behavior holds and spreads, that is evidence consistent with a trap: check which natural contingencies are maintaining it. If it fades, look for a different entry point or bait.
How to tell whether a trap is working
Seeing a skill generalize or last is a good sign, but on its own it does not prove a trap. Kohler and Greenwood point out that a generalized change could also come from teaching methods that program common stimuli, train loosely, or train enough examples. They describe five forms of evidence, best combined in a single study (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986):
- Generalization: the behavior changes across untrained settings or responses.
- Maintenance: the change continues after the original training stimuli have been removed.
- Temporal covariation: natural stimuli delivered by peers consistently come before or after the behavior.
- Functional analysis: when the peer stimuli are removed and then restored, the behavior reverses in the predicted directions.
- Systematic replication: the same peer stimuli have the same effect on other behaviors and in other settings.
Forms 1 to 3 are nonexperimental; forms 4 and 5 are experimental. The list is a useful check before crediting a trap: did the skill spread, did it last, and can you see who or what is reinforcing it?
Behavior trap or behavioral cusp?
The two terms describe related aspects of behavioral development. A behavioral cusp is an event or change that brings the learner into contact with new contingencies, and learning a new skill is one example; Becker, Kuhn and Pinkelman (2024) describe it as "an event that triggers contact with new behavioral contingencies." A behavior trap describes the environment: the natural reinforcement that keeps behavior going once the learner is in contact with it. In a 2022 review of five developmental concepts, Jiménez and colleagues proposed that behavioral traps be explicitly included in a cumulative-hierarchical learning framework, "to emphasize the environmental component" of how learning builds over time.
Our guide to choosing a target behavior explains cusps when deciding which skill to teach first. Students preparing for the RBT exam can practice related ideas with our RBT practice questions.
Learn about peer-mediated interventions
Peer Mediated Interventions: More Than Just Play Skills is a 140-minute webcast for school practitioners and teachers on training a child's classmates to help teach social and play skills. It comes with its downloadable slide deck. $39, a one-time purchase.
Questions about behavior traps
What is a behavior trap in ABA?
A natural contingency of reinforcement: once a person makes an entry response, reinforcement in everyday life, such as peers' responses, keeps the behavior going and can spread it to new behaviors, settings and times, without the teacher's planned rewards. (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986)
Who came up with the term behavior trap?
Donald Baer and Montrose Wolf, who described the idea in their 1970 chapter "The entry into natural communities of reinforcement." Kohler and Greenwood (1986) review the evidence that followed (KU ScholarWorks copy).
What is the difference between a behavior trap and a behavioral cusp?
A trap is the natural reinforcement in the environment that keeps behavior going. A cusp is an event or change, such as learning a new skill, that brings the person into contact with new contingencies. (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986; Becker, Kuhn and Pinkelman, 2024)
Can a behavior trap maintain problem behavior?
Yes. Kohler and Greenwood (1986) describe traps that support problematic behaviors and call for ways to reprogram them. (Kohler and Greenwood, 1986)
References
- Alber, S. R., & Heward, W. L. (1996). "GOTCHA!" Twenty-five behavior traps guaranteed to extend your students' academic and social skills. Intervention in School and Clinic, 31(5). ERIC EJ522902. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ522902
- Baer, D. M., & Wolf, M. M. (1970). The entry into natural communities of reinforcement. In R. Ulrich, T. Stachnik, & J. Mabry (Eds.), Control of human behavior (pp. 319–324). Scott Foresman. (Quoted as cited in Kohler and Greenwood, 1986.)
- Becker, A. M., Kuhn, R. M., & Pinkelman, S. E. (2024). Advancing and integrating the cusp concept to understand behavioral repertoire dynamics. Perspectives on Behavior Science. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40614-023-00389-8
- Jiménez, É. L. O., Tsutsumi, M. M. A., Laurenti, C., Silva Júnior, M., & Goulart, P. R. K. (2022). Integrative review of developmental behavior-analytic concepts. Perspectives on Behavior Science. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40614-022-00360-z
- Kohler, F. W., & Greenwood, C. R. (1986). Toward a technology of generalization: The identification of natural contingencies of reinforcement. The Behavior Analyst, 9(1), 19–26. https://kuscholarworks.ku.edu/entities/publication/b1e3f942-294e-4255-aeeb-00fd459fa2b5
- Stokes, T. F., & Baer, D. M. (1977). An implicit technology of generalization. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 10(2), 349–367. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.1977.10-349
