BACB ACE Provider · OP-14-2437• Founded 2010• 32,000+ customers• 140+ countries• V-CAT Consultation

From the blog

Reinforcement Meaning: Definition, Types and Examples

Special Learning · First published · Updated

Reinforcement means a consequence that follows a behavior and makes that behavior more likely to happen again. Reinforcement is defined by its effect on the behavior, not by whether the consequence seems pleasant. If a child gets a sticker after cleaning up and cleans up more often afterward, the sticker reinforced cleaning up. If cleaning up does not increase, the sticker was not a reinforcer for that child, however nice it seemed.

The APA Dictionary of Psychology defines reinforcement, in operant conditioning, as “a process in which the frequency or probability of a response is increased by a dependent relationship, or contingency, with a stimulus or circumstance (the reinforcer).” The reinforcer is the stimulus or circumstance in that contingency, such as the help a child gets after asking, if that help makes asking more likely; reinforcement is the process, or the procedure that produces the increase.

In everyday English, reinforcement also means making something stronger, and reinforcements are extra people sent to support a group. This page is about the meaning used in psychology, applied behavior analysis (ABA), parenting and teaching.

Positive and negative reinforcement

Both kinds make a behavior more likely. “Positive” and “negative” do not mean good and bad. They mean something is added or something is taken away.

  • Positive reinforcement: something is added after the behavior, and the behavior happens more often. Example: a child says “help, please” and an adult helps right away. If the child asks for help more often after that, the help positively reinforced asking.
  • Negative reinforcement: something unpleasant is removed, prevented or postponed after the behavior, and the behavior happens more often. The APA Dictionary describes it as “the removal, prevention, or postponement of an aversive stimulus as a consequence of a response, which, in turn, increases the probability of that response.” Example: you take medicine for a headache, the headache goes away, and you are more likely to take that medicine the next time.
Positive reinforcement: a child says help please, an adult helps right away, and the child asks for help more often. Negative reinforcement: an adult hands over candy, the crying stops, and handing over candy becomes more likely.Positive: something is addedBehaviorchild says"help, please"Addedadult helpsright awayMore likelyasks for helpmore oftenNegative: something is removedBehavioradult handsover candyRemovedthe cryingstopsMore likelyadult handsover candy again
The examples on this page. In each, the consequence can reinforce the behavior, if it then happens more often.

Negative reinforcement is not punishment. Punishment makes a behavior less likely; reinforcement of either kind makes it more likely.

Something is addedSomething is removed
Behavior becomes more likelyPositive reinforcementNegative reinforcement
Behavior becomes less likelyPositive punishmentNegative punishment

Primary and secondary reinforcers

  • Primary (unconditioned) reinforcers work without any special experience or training, such as food, water or warmth.
  • Secondary (conditioned) reinforcers start out neutral and become reinforcing because they have been paired with another reinforcer. Praise, stickers, tokens and money are common examples. The APA Dictionary gives the example of dog training: a clicker sound paired with a treat each time the dog sits can, over time, keep the behavior going with no treat at all.
A secondary reinforcer forms by pairing: a clicker sound paired with a treat each time a dog sits can, over time, keep the behavior going with the clicker alone.Clicker sound+Treatpaired each timethe dog sitsClicker sound alonekeeps sitting going
How a neutral sound becomes a secondary (conditioned) reinforcer, from the APA Dictionary's clicker example.

What works as a reinforcer differs from person to person and from day to day. A favorite snack may do nothing right after lunch. That is why ABA programs often use a preference assessment to identify items or activities that may serve as reinforcers, then watch whether they actually increase the behavior.

Schedules of reinforcement

A schedule of reinforcement is the rule that decides which instances of a behavior are reinforced. The main ones:

  • Continuous reinforcement: every correct response is reinforced (the same as a fixed-ratio 1 schedule).
  • Fixed ratio (FR): reinforcement after a set number of responses. FR 5 means after every fifth response.
  • Variable ratio (VR): reinforcement after a number of responses that changes; VR 10 means after 10 responses on average.
  • Fixed interval (FI): the first response after a set time has passed is reinforced. Responding often slows right after reinforcement and speeds up as the next one gets close, a pattern called the fixed-interval scallop.
  • Variable interval (VI): the first response after a changing amount of time is reinforced. It generally produces a fairly steady rate of responding.
Ratio schedules over 15 responses: continuous reinforces every response; fixed ratio 5 reinforces every fifth; variable ratio 5 reinforces after a changing number of responses that averages five.Continuous: every responseFixed ratio 5: every fifth responseVariable ratio 5: on average every fifthreinforcedone response
Three ratio schedules side by side. Interval schedules (FI and VI) instead reinforce the first response after an amount of time has passed.

Any schedule other than continuous is called intermittent (or partial) reinforcement: only some responses are reinforced. Moving from reinforcing every response to reinforcing some of them is called thinning the schedule.

Thin reinforcement with a token board

The Token Economy System shows you how to run a token board, a reward system many ABA programs use, with boards at 3, 5, 7 and 10 tokens so you can move to more tokens as the learner progresses, and six token designs to match the child. It includes a two-page guide to choosing behaviors and rewards, teaching what tokens mean, moving from 3 to 10 tokens, fading the board and troubleshooting. The download has 13 PDF files and costs $39.99, paid once.

See the Token Economy System

Reinforcement at home and in the classroom

  • At home: a child puts on their shoes when asked and gets to go outside right away. Going outside follows the behavior and can reinforce getting ready.
  • In the classroom: a student raises a hand and the teacher calls on them, instead of answering students who shout out. Being called on can reinforce hand-raising.
  • Without anyone planning it: a child cries at the checkout and gets candy to stop. The candy can reinforce crying at the checkout, and the quiet that follows can negatively reinforce the adult for handing over the candy.

The last example shows why timing matters. A consequence given after the behavior you want to see can reinforce that behavior, if the behavior then happens more often. Something handed over to stop a behavior that is already happening can reinforce the behavior you wanted to end.

Reinforcement tends to work better when it comes promptly after the behavior, uses something the learner is likely to value, is clearly tied to the behavior that earns it and follows the planned schedule consistently. Then watch whether the behavior actually increases. A free token board maker can help you set this up at home or in class.

Reinforcement tends to work better when it is prompt, valued by the learner, clearly tied to the behavior and consistent with the planned schedule; then watch whether the behavior increases.Promptright after the behaviorValuedby the learnerClearly tiedto what earns itConsistenton the planned scheduleThen watch the behaviordoes it increase?
What tends to make reinforcement work, and the check that follows.

Read next: reward vs reinforcement, for telling a reward from a reinforcer; the Premack principle, for using a more likely activity as the reinforcer ("first, then"); and behavior traps, for natural reinforcement that keeps a new skill going.

Reinforcement and extinction

If the reinforcer that has kept a behavior going stops following it, the behavior usually becomes less frequent over time. That is called extinction. Read Extinction in ABA: Definition, 3 Types and the Extinction Burst for how it works and why it should be part of a plan.

Sources

Copyright © by Special Learning Inc. All rights reserved.
No part of this article may be reproduced without written permission. For information, email contact@special-learning.com.

If you want to go further

Intro to ABA: Level 1

Learn ABA methods for daily practice with a course for parents, caregivers, educators and technicians. $199.

Explore Intro to ABA: Level 1

Start with the free ABCs of Autism.

BACB ACE Provider
#OP-14-2437
32,000+customers since 2010
140+countries
2010founded

Authorization as an ACE Provider does not imply endorsement or approval of the ACE event content by the BACB.

Free Tools and Guides From Special Learning

Every free tool and guide we have is on our free resources page right now. No spam, just helpful resources.