This guide shows where they differ, how to test which one you have, the main types of reinforcers, what research says about rewards and motivation, and five steps to make a reward work.
The difference between a reward and a reinforcer
The National Clearinghouse on Autism Evidence and Practice (NCAEP) defines reinforcement as "The application of a consequence following a learner’s use of a response or skills that increases the likelihood that the learner will use the response/skills in the future" (Steinbrenner et al., 2020). The key word is "increases." Reinforcement is named for its effect on behavior, not for how pleasant the consequence seems.
"Reward" has no such test built in. In everyday use, it means something given that the giver expects the person to like. Practitioner materials sometimes pair the two words: the AFIRM reinforcement worksheets ask teams to "identify and select reinforcers/rewards based on the learner’s preferred items, interests, and activities" (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024). The difference is functional: a reward is a reinforcer for a person only if it increases or maintains the behavior it follows.
NCAEP lists reinforcement as an evidence-based practice for autistic children, youth and young adults, and calls it foundational because it is almost always used with other practices, such as prompting, discrete trial teaching, functional communication training and naturalistic intervention (Steinbrenner et al., 2020).
The test: did the behavior increase?
Because reinforcement is defined by its effect, you look for evidence in the behavior over time. If receiving a favorite snack after putting toys away makes future cleanup more likely, the snack functions as a reinforcer for cleanup. If the data do not show the intended effect, review the snack, how and when it is delivered, and whether the plan is carried out as written. (An example written for this guide.) A reinforcer can also keep up a skill the learner already uses, so a steady rate is not, by itself, proof that nothing is reinforcing it; AFIRM's monitoring steps look at reinforcement sufficient to maintain the behavior (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024).
This is why the same item can reinforce one person and not another, or work on Monday and not on Friday. AFIRM describes satiation: "Satiation refers to when a selected reinforcer is no longer motivating to a learner," and notes that a reinforcer used too often often becomes less effective (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024).
Types of reinforcers
The AFIRM team, at the University of North Carolina's Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute, groups reinforcers into types (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024):
- Material or activity reinforcers, such as play activities, computer access and stickers. They motivate, but teams should vary them so the learner does not grow tired of them.
- Natural reinforcers, which happen as a natural result of the behavior, such as receiving a good grade after studying, or receiving water after signing for "more."
- Sensory reinforcers, such as rocking in a rocking chair. AFIRM advises using these only when the adult can control access, the reinforcer is acceptable for the setting, and no other reinforcer is as motivating.
- Social reinforcers, such as smiles or sitting beside the teacher. They are found in any setting but may need to be taught if they are not already reinforcing for the learner.
A natural reinforcer, like water after asking for it, is simply the result the behavior produces.
Positive and negative reinforcement
Both increase behavior. AFIRM defines positive reinforcement as "the delivery of a reinforcer (primary, such as food, or secondary, such as verbal praise or toys) after the learner uses a target skill or behavior." Negative reinforcement "removes an aversive or unwanted stimulus after the learner uses a target skill or behavior," and AFIRM stresses that it is not the same as punishment: negative reinforcement increases a target behavior, while punishment decreases one (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024).
A token economy is a type of positive reinforcement in which learners earn tokens they can exchange for desired reinforcers, known as backup reinforcers (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024). See also our guide to the Premack principle. For the wider topic, see our article on what reinforcement means.
Do rewards hurt motivation?
A common worry is that rewards reduce a person's own interest in an activity. Cameron, Banko and Pierce (2001) ran a meta-analysis of the experimental studies on this question. Their results suggest that, in general, rewards are not harmful to motivation to perform a task. Rewards given for low-interest tasks increased free-choice intrinsic motivation. On high-interest tasks, verbal rewards produced positive effects on free-choice motivation and self-reported interest.
They did find negative effects in one set of conditions: on high-interest tasks, when the rewards were tangible, expected (offered beforehand) and loosely tied to level of performance. When rewards were linked to level of performance, measures of intrinsic motivation increased or did not differ from a group that got no reward (Cameron, Banko and Pierce, 2001).
They note that an earlier meta-analysis by Deci, Koestner and Ryan (1999) reported pervasive negative effects of reward, and their article set out to resolve the difference. Their overall conclusion is that reward contingencies do not have pervasive negative effects on intrinsic motivation (Cameron, Banko and Pierce, 2001).
How to make a reward work as reinforcement
AFIRM's reinforcement steps turn a reward into reinforcement you can check (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024):
- Find what the learner chooses. Identify reinforcers from the learner's preferred items, interests and activities. AFIRM's pictorial menu lets the learner pick a preferred object, activity or food before working on the target skill.
- Deliver it after the skill, and name what they did. When teaching a new skill, give the reinforcer each time the learner uses it, and describe the skill, for example: "You completed your assignment, now you can read your book."
- Check the data. Is the consequence increasing the skill, or maintaining it once learned? If the data do not show the intended effect, review the chosen consequence, how it is delivered and how the plan is carried out (Steinbrenner et al., 2020; Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024).
- Vary it. Use a menu of reinforcers to prevent satiation.
- Thin it. Once the learner meets the first performance goal, move to an intermittent schedule, and use reinforcers consistently across settings.
Students preparing for the RBT exam can practice these terms with our RBT practice questions.
Find out what the learner wants
The Preference Assessments training shows how to run a preference assessment to find out what a learner wants, with a worked demonstration. The webcast reviews the research, then walks through the multiple-stimulus-without-replacement (MSWO) format: choosing the items, running it, scoring it and using the results in planning. It comes with its downloadable slide deck. $39, a one-time purchase.
Questions about rewards and reinforcement
What is the difference between a reward and reinforcement?
A reward is something given that the giver expects the person to like. Reinforcement is the application of a consequence after a behavior that increases the likelihood the person will use that behavior in the future; the consequence is the reinforcer. A reward functions as a reinforcer when delivering it after a behavior makes that behavior more likely. (Steinbrenner et al., 2020)
Is positive reinforcement the same as a reward?
Not always. Positive reinforcement is delivering a reinforcer after the learner uses a target skill. A reward functions as a reinforcer when delivering it after a behavior makes that behavior more likely. That process is positive reinforcement. (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024)
Is negative reinforcement punishment?
No. In negative reinforcement, removing an aversive or unwanted stimulus after the skill increases the skill. Punishment decreases a behavior. (Sam and AFIRM Team, 2024)
Do rewards hurt motivation?
A 2001 meta-analysis by Cameron, Banko and Pierce found that, in general, rewards are not harmful to motivation to perform a task. Negative effects appeared on high-interest tasks when rewards were tangible, expected and loosely tied to performance. (Cameron, Banko and Pierce, 2001)
References
- Cameron, J., Banko, K. M., & Pierce, W. D. (2001). Pervasive negative effects of rewards on intrinsic motivation: The myth continues. The Behavior Analyst, 24(1), 1–44. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF03392017
- Sam, A., & AFIRM Team. (2024 update). Reinforcement: EBP brief packet. Autism Focused Intervention Resources and Modules, Frank Porter Graham Child Development Institute, University of North Carolina. https://afirm.fpg.unc.edu/wp-content/uploads/Reinforcement-Brief-Packet-Sam-AFIRM-Team-Updated-2024.pdf
- Steinbrenner, J. R., Hume, K., Odom, S. L., Morin, K. L., Nowell, S. W., Tomaszewski, B., Szendrey, S., McIntyre, N. S., Yücesoy-Özkan, Ş., & Savage, M. N. (2020). Evidence-based practices for children, youth, and young adults with autism. National Clearinghouse on Autism Evidence and Practice, University of North Carolina. https://ncaep.fpg.unc.edu/wp-content/uploads/EBP-Report-2020.pdf
