This guide explains the principle from the research it came from, shows how studies have used it, and covers the later finding called response deprivation, which changes how you choose the "then." It ends with five steps for using a first-then plan at home or in a classroom.
What the Premack principle says
The principle comes from David Premack's research in 1959. Klatt and Morris (2001) quote his rule: "any response A will reinforce any response B, if and only if, the independent rate of A is greater than that of B." In everyday terms, the "independent rate" is how often a person does an activity when they are free to choose. A higher-rate activity can reinforce a lower-rate activity, but not the other way around (Klatt and Morris, 2001).
Klatt and Morris give the laboratory version: the chance for a rat to drink water will reinforce its wheel running if, and only if, drinking is more probable than running. They add that this is not just a theoretical point; it has clinical and applied uses, many of them already put into practice (Klatt and Morris, 2001).
What makes the principle useful is that the reinforcer is an activity, not an object. Nothing has to be bought or handed out. The "then" can be any activity the person already does often: a game, drawing, time outside, or a conversation about a favorite topic.
Why it is called Grandma's law
Speer and Maag (2025) note that the Premack principle is "often referred to as Grandma's law." They describe it as people completing a harder or less wanted activity when they get access to a wanted activity after finishing it (Speer and Maag, 2025). A 1993 Council for Exceptional Children manual by Ennio Cipani calls the same kind of strategy, using a highly preferred activity to reinforce compliance with a disliked activity, "Grandma's rule" (Cipani, 1993). A household version, written for this guide: "First your vegetables, then dessert." Our archive article on Grandma's law by Amanda Fishley, MA, BCBA, gives more everyday examples.
Finding the more likely activity
The principle depends on knowing which activity is more probable for this person, today. That is something you observe, not something you assume. The most direct way is to watch what the person does during free time, when nothing is required and several activities are available, and note how long they spend on each.
The answer can differ between people and can change from day to day. An activity that one child chooses for half an hour may be one that another child avoids. Asking the person, and their family, about what they enjoy helps, but the free-time record is the stronger guide because it shows what they actually do.
What the research shows
Klatt and Morris point to applied studies that used the principle. In one, Allen and Iwata (1980) increased exercise among people with developmental disabilities by making access to games depend on exercising first (Klatt and Morris, 2001).
A 1973 study shows that the "then" does not have to be something most people would call a treat. Mitchell and Stoffelmayr (1973) worked with four patients with schizophrenia, chosen as the least active on a hospital ward for people with long-term illness. Two of them repeatedly refused every reward that could be handed out. Applying Premack's principle, the researchers used the chance to sit as the reinforcer and shaped and maintained consistent work. They concluded that the principle may be especially useful for people who refuse tangible rewards.
In schools, Speer and Maag (2025) describe the principle as a way to encourage students to complete work while avoiding problem behavior, without drastic changes to the classroom, buying tangible rewards, or using exclusionary discipline. Their article is a guide for teachers putting it in place (Speer and Maag, 2025).
Response deprivation: the update to the rule
Later research found that relative probability is not the whole story. Premack (1965) noted that when the more probable activity was used as a reinforcer, it was held below its usual level until the less probable activity happened. In 1967, Eisenberger and colleagues showed this restriction was the key: any response can reinforce another if its rate is held below its free-operant baseline, regardless of which one happens more often. In their study, the chance for people to turn a wheel reinforced bar pressing whether wheel turning was the higher or the lower rate activity, as long as it was held below its baseline (Klatt and Morris, 2001).
Timberlake and Allison (1974) reformulated this idea as response deprivation, which Klatt and Morris call the more standard term today. Their conclusion is direct: the Premack principle, as originally stated, is incomplete, and is explained by response deprivation, which expands its scope and precision. They classify response deprivation as an establishing operation: it temporarily increases the reinforcing effectiveness of the chance to do the restricted activity, and evokes behavior that has led to that chance before (Klatt and Morris, 2001).
The reverse also holds. Klatt and Morris describe response satiation: when an activity is pushed above its baseline level, the chance to do more of it can work as a punisher rather than a reinforcer (Klatt and Morris, 2001). In practice, the arrangement matters, not only how much the person likes the "then": what counts is how access compares with their usual free-choice level.
How to use the Premack principle: five steps
These steps are written for this guide from the sources above. They work for a parent at home, a teacher in class, or a behavior technician following a plan written by a supervising behavior analyst.
- Watch free time. Note what the person chooses, and for how long, when nothing is required.
- Pick the "then." Choose an activity they do more often than the "first." If you are using response deprivation instead, know the activity's usual free-choice level and arrange access that stays below it unless the "first" is done.
- Say it as first-then. Keep the "first" short and clear. Make the plan together where you can, and offer choices. A picture board can help; our free first-then board maker prints one.
- Keep the promise. When the "first" is done, give access to the "then" as agreed.
- Check the data. Is the "first" activity happening more often? If not, look again at what is more likely for this person, and at how access to the "then" compares with their usual level.
What gets in the way
- The order of the plan. The "then" is access that depends on finishing the "first." Premack's original rule predicts reinforcement from the more probable activity to the less probable one; under response deprivation, a less probable activity held below its usual level can also reinforce a more probable one (Klatt and Morris, 2001).
- A "then" that is never restricted. If the activity is freely available, it may not be held below its usual level, so access to it may not reinforce the "first." Response satiation is the other end: when an activity is forced above its usual level, the chance to do more of it can lose its pull or work as a punisher (Klatt and Morris, 2001).
- Guessing instead of watching. What adults think a child prefers and what the child chooses are not always the same. The free-time record settles it.
Students preparing for the RBT exam can practice reinforcement questions with our RBT practice questions, and our guide to behavior traps covers how natural reinforcement keeps a new skill going.
Make the "then" visible
The Token Economy System is a download that shows you how to run a token board, a reward system many ABA programs use, with boards at 3, 5, 7 and 10 tokens. It is made for parents, teachers and RBTs. $39.99, a one-time purchase. To try the idea first, our free token board maker builds a board in your browser.
Questions about the Premack principle
What is the Premack principle?
A rule from David Premack's 1959 research: a more probable activity can reinforce a less probable activity when access to the more probable one depends on doing the less probable one first. It is often called Grandma's law. (Klatt and Morris, 2001; Speer and Maag, 2025)
Why is it called Grandma's law or Grandma's rule?
The names describe a familiar arrangement: do the less wanted task first, then get to do the wanted activity. Speer and Maag (2025) note that the Premack principle is often referred to as Grandma's law, and a 1993 Council for Exceptional Children manual calls the strategy of using a highly preferred activity to reinforce compliance with a disliked activity Grandma's rule. (Speer and Maag, 2025; Cipani, 1993)
What is the difference between the Premack principle and response deprivation?
The Premack principle says the more probable activity reinforces the less probable one. Response deprivation, from Timberlake and Allison (1974), says any activity held below its usual baseline level can reinforce another, whichever happens more often. Klatt and Morris (2001) describe the Premack principle as explained by response deprivation. (Klatt and Morris, 2001)
Does the reinforcer have to be a toy, food or prize?
No. In the Premack principle the reinforcer is the chance to do an activity. In one study, the chance to sit served as the reinforcer for work. (Mitchell and Stoffelmayr, 1973)
References
- Cipani, E. (1993). Non-compliance: Four strategies that work. CEC Mini-Library: Classroom Management. Council for Exceptional Children. ERIC ED361973. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED361973
- Klatt, K. P., & Morris, E. K. (2001). The Premack principle, response deprivation, and establishing operations. The Behavior Analyst, 24(2), 173–180. https://kuscholarworks.ku.edu/entities/publication/a3d0ef92-2e7e-4a7d-8c65-d86d71ebe29c
- Mitchell, W. S., & Stoffelmayr, B. E. (1973). Application of the Premack principle to the behavioral control of extremely inactive schizophrenics. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 6(3), 419–423. https://doi.org/10.1901/jaba.1973.6-419
- Premack, D. (1959). Toward empirical behavior laws: I. Positive reinforcement. Psychological Review, 66, 219–233. (Quoted as cited in Klatt and Morris, 2001.)
- Speer, N. C., & Maag, J. W. (2025). Improving student behavior with restrictive access to high probability responses: The Premack principle in the elementary classroom. Intervention in School and Clinic. ERIC EJ1479483. https://eric.ed.gov/?id=EJ1479483
