BACB ACE Provider · OP-14-2437• Founded 2010• 32,000+ customers• 140+ countries• V-CAT Consultation

From the blog

Irlen Syndrome and Irlen Lenses: What the Evidence Says

Special Learning · First published · Updated

Irlen syndrome, also called scotopic sensitivity syndrome or Meares-Irlen syndrome, is a proposed condition in which reading is said to be hampered by how a person sees light, color and print. Irlen lenses and overlays are tinted filters sold to ease it. Systematic reviews have not found reliable evidence that colored lenses or overlays improve reading, and the major pediatric eye groups do not recommend them. At the same time, many autistic people describe real sensitivity to light, patterns and color, and that deserves a careful answer. This page covers what the research says and what to do first.

What is Irlen syndrome?

A 2019 systematic review by Miyasaka and colleagues describes the syndrome as symptoms of poor reading ability attributed to poor color matching and distorted graphic images, with visual fatigue. The authors note it is still uncertain whether it is a condition of its own or part of the dyslexia spectrum, and they found high variation among studies and a lack of evidence on whether the syndrome exists as described and whether its treatments work.

In a 2011 trial by Ritchie and colleagues, an Irlen diagnostician assessed 61 schoolchildren with reading difficulties and diagnosed Irlen syndrome in 77% of them. The trial's authors call it a proposed perceptual disorder with controversial diagnostic status.

Do Irlen lenses and colored overlays help reading?

The research does not show a reliable benefit. A 2016 systematic review by Griffiths and colleagues examined 51 published items covering four color systems, including Irlen. Results did not differ by system. Most studies carried a high or uncertain risk of bias, and the better-designed studies gave less support for colored lenses or overlays. Where studies did report improvement, the effect was generally small or similar to a placebo. The authors concluded that colored lenses or overlays for reading difficulties cannot be endorsed, and that benefits people report are likely due to placebo, practice or the extra attention of being studied.

A 2018 overview by Suttle and colleagues compared four systematic reviews. Three concluded there is not enough good-quality evidence to support colored overlays or lenses for reading difficulty; one concluded the evidence does support them. On balance, the authors found no reliable evidence base yet, and called for high-quality research.

What three systematic reviews found about colored lenses and overlaysGriffiths and colleagues, 201651 published items reviewedbenefit small or similar to placeboSuttle and colleagues, 20184 systematic reviews compared3 of 4: not enough good evidenceMiyasaka and colleagues, 2019systematic review of Irlen syndromeevidence lacking for diagnosis and treatment
Sources: Griffiths and colleagues (2016), Ophthalmic and Physiological Optics; Suttle and colleagues (2018), Clinical and Experimental Optometry; Miyasaka and colleagues (2019), Arquivos de Neuro-Psiquiatria.

The Ritchie trial tested Irlen overlays directly. Each child read with an overlay in the color the diagnostician prescribed, with an overlay in a different color, and with no overlay. In a subset of 44 children diagnosed with Irlen syndrome, the researchers also compared groups on a broader reading measure. They found no evidence of any immediate benefit from the Irlen overlays on either measure.

How one trial tested Irlen overlays with 61 childrenChildren with reading difficulties, ages 7 to 12Overlay in the prescribed colorOverlay in a different colorNo overlayResult: no immediate benefitfrom the prescribed color
The Irlen diagnostician diagnosed Irlen syndrome in 77% of these children with reading difficulties. Source: Ritchie, Della Sala and McIntosh (2011), Pediatrics.

What pediatric eye doctors say

A 2009 joint statement from the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Academy of Ophthalmology, the American Association for Pediatric Ophthalmology and Strabismus (AAPOS) and the American Association of Certified Orthoptists says that vision problems can interfere with learning but are not the cause of primary dyslexia or learning disabilities, and that special tinted filters or lenses lack scientific evidence and should not be recommended.

The groups' 2011 report adds that children with dyslexia or related learning disabilities have the same visual function and eye health as other children, and that scientific evidence does not support colored lenses and filters as treatments for learning disabilities. For dyslexia, it recommends instruction aimed at language: decoding, fluency, vocabulary and comprehension, usually taught daily and individually, with explicit teaching of phonemic awareness and phonics.

What four pediatric eye and pediatrics groups say about vision and readingVision problemscan interfere with readingThey are not the causeof primary dyslexiaChildren with dyslexiasame visual function and eye healthTinted filters or lensesshould not be recommended
American Academy of Pediatrics, American Academy of Ophthalmology, AAPOS and American Association of Certified Orthoptists. Sources: joint statement (2009) and report (2011), Pediatrics.

What about autism?

Three studies, all from a research group including Ludlow and Wilkins, have looked at colored filters with autistic children. In a 2006 study, 15 of 19 autistic children (79%) read at least 5% faster with a colored overlay, compared with 3 of 19 matched peers (16%). In a 2012 study, autistic children judged the emotion shown in photographs of eyes better when the photograph was covered by a colored overlay, while the comparison group showed no significant change. In a 2020 masked randomized study of 14 autistic children aged 10 to 14 and 14 comparison children matched on verbal and nonverbal IQ, the autistic group did better on two social tasks with tinted lenses in the color each child had chosen a month earlier than with lenses of a slightly different color.

These results are interesting but early. The 2006 and 2020 studies had small samples. The studies tested colored overlays or precision ophthalmic tints (the 2006 study names Intuitive Coloured Overlays); they do not establish a benefit from Irlen-branded lenses. The Griffiths review, which included the Intuitive system, found that the better-designed studies gave less support for benefits to reading; it did not test social tasks like those in the 2012 and 2020 studies.

Three studies of colored overlays and tints with autistic childrenStudies by Ludlow, Wilkins and colleagues2006: reading speed19 autistic children, 19 matched peers79% vs 16% read 5%+ faster2012: emotions in eyesoverlay improved judgmentsin the autistic group only2020: tinted lenses, masked14 autistic children, 14 matchedbetter on 2 social tasks
Colored overlays or precision ophthalmic tints; these do not establish a benefit from Irlen-branded lenses. Sources: Ludlow, Wilkins and Heaton (2006); Ludlow, Taylor-Whiffen and Wilkins (2012); Ludlow and colleagues (2020).

Visual sensitivity in autism is real

Many autistic people describe the way light and patterns feel to them. In a 2021 study by Parmar and colleagues, 18 autistic adults described sensitivity to light, motion, patterns and particular colors, often as part of a wider sensory picture. They said it caused distraction, fatigue and stress and got in the way of daily life, such as travel and social activities. They used a variety of coping strategies, with varied success, and those who understood their visual experiences better felt less worried about them.

So if your child squints at bright lights, avoids striped or busy patterns, or tires quickly when reading, take these experiences seriously and discuss them with your child's doctor. If reading is a concern, seek reading support; the reviews summarized here do not provide a reliable basis for recommending colored lenses or overlays to improve reading.

What to do first

  • Start with an eye exam. AAPOS advises a consultation with an ophthalmologist for children who fail a vision screening, so that treatable eye conditions, such as a need for glasses or an eye muscle imbalance, are found and treated.
  • If reading is the worry, ask the school. AAPOS notes that most schools will run a special education evaluation if you request it in writing, and suggests talking with the school about an Individualized Education Program (IEP) or a 504 plan.
  • If light or patterns bother your child, keep notes. Write down when it happens, where, and what seems to help, and share the notes with your child's doctor and team. Like the adults in the Parmar study, many people find their own strategies, and understanding the experience can make it less worrying.
  • If you try tinted lenses or overlays anyway, ask whoever recommends them how you will both tell whether they work. Researchers compare the chosen color with a different color and with no tint, which helps tell a color-specific benefit apart from practice or placebo effects.
Four steps if you are wondering about Irlen lenses for your child1. Eye exam firsttreatable problems: glasses, eye muscles2. Reading a concern?ask the school in writing to evaluate3. Light or patterns hard?note when, where and what helps4. Trying tints anyway?agree how you will tell if it works
Sources: AAPOS, Learning Disabilities glossary entry; Handler and colleagues (2011), Pediatrics; Parmar and colleagues (2021).

Common questions

Is Irlen syndrome real?

It is a proposed condition with controversial diagnostic status. A 2019 systematic review found a lack of evidence on whether the syndrome exists as described and whether its treatments work. Discomfort with light or patterns can be real for a person, which is why an eye exam is the place to start.

Do Irlen lenses help autistic children?

The research summarized here does not establish that Irlen lenses help autistic children. Three studies of colored overlays and tints found improvements in reading speed and in reading emotions with autistic children, two of them with small samples, and reviews of colored lenses and overlays for reading found that better-designed studies showed less benefit.

Who should check my child's vision?

Start with your child's regular vision screening. AAPOS advises a consultation with an ophthalmologist, an eye doctor, for children who fail a vision screening, so treatable problems like a need for glasses or an eye muscle imbalance can be found.

Sources

Copyright © by Special Learning Inc. All right reserved.

No part of this article may be reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For information, contact Special Learning Inc., at: contact@special-learning.com

If you want to go further

The Intro to Autism Bundle: two recorded introductions and five resources

Intro to Autism Bundle

Two recorded introductions to autism and ABA with Sarah Winningham and Michele LaMarche, plus five digital resources on introductory concepts and asking for help, for parents, educators and professionals looking for an introduction.

$79 · 3 months' access

See the bundle

Not ready to buy? The starter guide is free.

BACB ACE Provider
#OP-14-2437
32,000+customers since 2010
140+countries
2010founded

Authorization as an ACE Provider does not imply endorsement or approval of the ACE event content by the BACB.

Free Tools and Guides From Special Learning

Every free tool and guide we have is on our free resources page right now. No spam, just helpful resources.