BACB ACE Provider · OP-14-2437• Founded 2010• 32,000+ customers• 140+ countries• V-CAT Consultation

From the blog

Prompting in ABA: Definition, 6 Prompt Types and How to Fade Them

Special Learning · First published · Updated

Prompting means giving a learner extra help so they respond correctly. That help is then faded until they can respond on their own. A prompt is added to the instruction or the situation: a spoken hint, a point, a demonstration or a hand guiding the learner's hand. The goal is to give less and less help until the learner can respond to the instruction itself.

In applied behavior analysis (ABA), a parent, teacher or therapist gives the instruction (for example, “Touch the ball”), adds a prompt if the learner needs it, and reinforces the correct response. Making that help smaller, later or less intrusive, step by step, until the learner responds to the instruction alone is called prompt fading.

The 6 prompt types, from most to least intrusive

“Intrusive” means how much the prompt does for the learner. Here is one common order, the one on our free prompt hierarchy card:

  1. Full physical: hand-over-hand guidance through the whole response. Example: guiding the learner's hand all the way to place a puzzle piece.
  2. Partial physical: a light touch, nudge or partial assist that gives some physical guidance without completing the movement for the learner. Example: a gentle tap on the elbow to start reaching.
  3. Modeling: you show the response and the learner copies it. Example: you touch the ball, then say “You do it.”
  4. Gestural: a point, nod or look toward the right answer, with no touch. Example: pointing to the correct picture card.
  5. Visual or positional: a picture, written cue or the placement of materials guides the response. Example: putting the correct card a little closer to the learner.
  6. Verbal: a spoken hint or part of the answer. Example: saying the first sound, “B…”, when the learner is naming a ball.
Ladder of the 6 prompt types from most to least intrusive: full physical, partial physical, modeling, gestural, visual or positional, verbal.More help1. Full physical2. Partial physical3. Modeling4. Gestural5. Visual or positional6. VerbalLess help
The 6 prompt types in the order used on our free prompt hierarchy card. A learner’s ABA team may choose a different order.

The order is a guide, not a rule. Some learners find a spoken prompt hard to fade, and some find a gesture easier than a picture. If your child or student has an ABA team, they choose the prompt types and the order for each learner and each skill.

Most-to-least and least-to-most prompting

  • Most-to-least (MTL): start with the prompt that makes a correct response very likely, often physical guidance, and move to smaller prompts as the learner succeeds. Because the learner makes few mistakes, MTL is often used for errorless teaching.
  • Least-to-most (LTM): give the instruction and wait a few seconds for the learner to respond alone. If they don't respond correctly, give the least intrusive prompt, and move up the order only as far as needed.
  • Prompt delay: give the instruction and the prompt together at first, then wait a little longer before prompting (for example, 0, then 2, then 4 seconds). The learner gets a chance to answer before the help arrives. When the wait grows step by step, it is called a progressive prompt delay; when it stays the same after the first trials, a constant prompt delay.
Comparison: most-to-least starts with the most help and fades it; least-to-most waits, then gives the least help first and adds more only as needed.Most-to-leastLeast-to-mostStart withthe most helpUse smaller promptsas the learner succeedsInstruction, thenwait a few secondsLeast help first,more only if neededMTL: few errors, often used for errorless teaching
Most-to-least and least-to-most prompting, as described above.
Timeline: the prompt comes with the instruction at first, then after 2 seconds, then after 4 seconds, giving the learner a chance to answer first.Prompt delay: the wait before help growsFirst trialsAskPromptNextAsk2 secondsPromptLaterAsk4 secondsPrompt
The prompt delay example from this article: 0, then 2, then 4 seconds.

What studies found

No single prompting method works best for every learner. Two studies with children with autism show why:

  • Libby and colleagues (2008) compared MTL and LTM while teaching children to build Lego play structures. All participants learned with MTL, and MTL produced fewer errors than LTM, but three participants learned faster with LTM. In a second study, MTL with a delay before the prompt was nearly as fast as LTM and still produced fewer errors.
  • Schnell and colleagues (2020) ran instructional assessments to find the most efficient prompt type and prompt-fading procedure for children with autism. The most efficient prompt type differed from child to child, while least-to-most fading was the most efficient method for every participant.

The practical lesson: try a method, record whether each response was independent or prompted, and change the plan when the data show slow progress or many errors.

How to fade prompts and avoid prompt dependence

Prompt dependence means the learner waits for the prompt instead of responding to the instruction. These habits help prevent it:

  • Plan the fading before you start: decide how many correct responses at one prompt level move you to the next.
  • Follow a prompted response with a transfer trial when your plan calls for one: give the instruction again with less help. Avoid repeating instructions without a plan, since the repetition itself can become a cue the learner waits for.
  • Reinforce independent responses more than prompted ones, so answering alone is worth more to the learner.
  • Watch for prompts you don't mean to give, such as looking at the right answer, pausing before it or changing your tone.
  • Write down the prompt level on every trial, so you can see whether help is really shrinking.

Print the free prompt hierarchy card to keep the 6 levels and the MTL and LTM steps next to you while you teach. Prompts work together with reinforcement: read Reinforcement Meaning: Definition, Types and Examples for how to make correct responses more likely to happen again.

Sources

  • Libby, M. E., Weiss, J. S., Bancroft, S., & Ahearn, W. H. (2008). A comparison of most-to-least and least-to-most prompting on the acquisition of solitary play skills. Behavior Analysis in Practice, 1(1), 37–43. doi.org/10.1007/BF03391719
  • Schnell, L. K., Vladescu, J. C., Kisamore, A. N., DeBar, R. M., Kahng, S., & Marano, K. (2020). Assessment to identify learner-specific prompt and prompt-fading procedures for children with autism spectrum disorder. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 53(2), 1111–1129. doi.org/10.1002/jaba.623

Copyright © by Special Learning Inc. All rights reserved.
No part of this article may be reproduced without written permission. For information, email contact@special-learning.com.

If you want to go further

Intro to ABA: Level 1

Learn ABA methods for daily practice with a course for parents, caregivers, educators and technicians. $199.

Explore Intro to ABA: Level 1

Start with the free ABCs of Autism.

BACB ACE Provider
#OP-14-2437
32,000+customers since 2010
140+countries
2010founded

Authorization as an ACE Provider does not imply endorsement or approval of the ACE event content by the BACB.

Free Tools and Guides From Special Learning

Every free tool and guide we have is on our free resources page right now. No spam, just helpful resources.