Skip to the toolkit

For agency owners and hiring leads

Structured interview scorecard for agency hiring

Prepare consistent, job-related questions and record the evidence for your decision. Print one copy per candidate after your hiring team adapts it to the role.

Define job skills, ask the same core questions, and rate evidence using shared anchors.
Adapted from the U.S. Office of Personnel Management’s structured interview guidance, which describes a common question order and rating scale.

Prepare once for the role

  1. Choose up to three skills that are important to this particular job. Check them against the actual job description and the responsibilities of the role.
  2. Write a question and define what stronger evidence would look like for each skill before interviewing. Use the same core questions and order, and prepare consistent follow-up prompts, while making appropriate individually determined accommodations to the interview process.
  3. Agree on the rating anchors and interview roles in advance. Explain the interview format to each candidate and offer a route to request an accommodation for the hiring process.

OPM describes structured interviews for federal hiring. This worksheet adapts those practices for agency teams. The EEOC’s guidance discusses accommodation in the application process and pre-offer medical questions. Before an offer, generally do not ask disability-related or medical questions. Under the ADA, an employer cannot ask all applicants before an offer whether they need an accommodation to perform the job. EEOC guidance describes a limited exception for certain individual applicants. Asking about accommodation for the hiring process is different. Keep notes job-related; follow your organization’s recruiting and records procedures, including its separate, confidential process for medical information.

Role scorecard: print one per candidate

Role: __________________________________   Interview date: __________________

Interviewer: ______________________________   Candidate reference: __________________

The headings and prompts below are examples to replace with your approved role-specific versions. Write your approved role-specific questions and probes in the spaces below, then use them consistently with appropriate process accommodations. A candidate may use a relevant example from paid work, volunteering, education or another experience.

1. Communication and teamwork

Prompt: Tell us about a time you needed to share an important update with a team. What did you communicate, and what happened next?

Chosen competency: _______________________   Approved question and probes: ______________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________
Evidence relevant to this role: ______________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________

Rating: 1 / 2 / 3 / insufficient evidence   Follow-up needed: __________________________

2. Following a plan and asking for help

Prompt: Describe a time you were given a process to follow and were unsure what to do next. What did you do?

Chosen competency: _______________________   Approved question and probes: ______________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________
Evidence relevant to this role: ______________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________

Rating: 1 / 2 / 3 / insufficient evidence   Follow-up needed: __________________________

3. Responding to change

Prompt: Tell us about a time a plan changed during your day. How did you decide what to do and communicate the change?

Chosen competency: _______________________   Approved question and probes: ______________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________
Evidence relevant to this role: ______________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________

Rating: 1 / 2 / 3 / insufficient evidence   Follow-up needed: __________________________

Use shared job-specific rating anchors; distinguish weak evidence from missing evidence.
Scoring practice adapted from OPM’s structured interview guide.

Example shared rating anchors

Before interviews, attach a separate prepared scoring guide with level-specific behavioral anchors for each skill and enough space for notes, and agree on what evidence would demonstrate each skill. Use the same job-related criteria for every candidate while making appropriate process accommodations. For each skill, write examples of effective and ineffective job-related actions before interviews:
Skill and anchors: __________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________________

  • 1: The response gives relevant evidence of actions or reasoning that do not meet the role-specific standard.
  • 2: The response gives relevant evidence that partly meets the role-specific standard.
  • 3: The response gives relevant evidence of actions or reasoning that meet the role-specific standard.
  • Insufficient evidence: There is not enough relevant information to judge against the standard; record what remains unknown rather than assuming a low score.

These are sample anchors, not a validated test or automatic hiring decision. Consider the full job-related evidence and your organization’s approved process.

Close the loop

What evidence supports the next step? ________________________________________________

What still needs checking, who owns it, and by when? __________________________________

Prepare for a new hire’s first day

Coordinate the start plan, access and open items with a printable checklist.

Open the first-day readiness checklist

Explore the agency training toolkit · More resources for organizations