For ABA agency owners
ESOP or outside sale? Compare your agency succession options
The right transition depends on your goals, the terms available and the people who rely on your agency. Use this worksheet to prepare for a conversation with your attorney, tax adviser and valuation professional.
An employee stock ownership plan (ESOP) is a qualified defined-contribution retirement plan designed to invest primarily in employer securities. Its trust can hold part or all of a company. An outside sale can be structured as a sale of ownership interests or business assets under negotiated terms. Explore both with the same questions. Sources: IRS: ESOPs, U.S. Department of Labor: employee ownership, and SBA: managing and selling a business.
A decision path for either option
- Goals: What must the transition accomplish?
- Terms: What interest, valuation and payment structure are proposed?
- People: Who makes decisions, and how are staff affected?
- Execution: What financing, costs and next steps apply?
Compare the questions, not just the headline price
ESOP
- What portion would the plan acquire, how would the shares be valued, and what is the trustee’s role?
- How would the transaction be financed, and what are the setup and ongoing costs?
- What roles would the trustee, board and management have after the transaction?
- Who would participate, how would vesting and distributions work, and what future share-repurchase obligations should the agency plan for?
Outside buyer
- Would the buyer acquire ownership interests or assets, and what valuation and payment terms are proposed?
- What fees, financing conditions or other transaction costs apply?
- Who would make decisions after closing, and what role would the current owner have?
- What does the buyer propose for staff, operations and continuity of services?
Ask each adviser to identify what is known, what needs to be verified and how the structure, taxes, payment risk and costs could affect your net proceeds and the agency’s future. Neither route has a single standard outcome.
Your comparison worksheet
Write questions or priorities below. Entries stay in this browser page and are not saved: print or save as a PDF to keep a copy. Avoid entering confidential financial or personal details on a shared device.
Received a purchase proposal?
Prepare for your adviser conversation with questions about the letter of intent, price, deadlines and potentially binding terms.
Open the agency sale LOI guidePreparing for a valuation?
Organize the scope, records and questions for a meeting with an appraiser.
Open the valuation meeting guideRead the employee ownership introduction · More resources for organizations
