BACB ACE Provider · OP-14-2437• Founded 2010• 32,000+ customers• 140+ countries• V-CAT Consultation

Error correction

Error correction is a short set of steps, written into a learner's plan, for the moment after a wrong answer or no answer. Plans differ in the steps: some repeat the trial, and others show the right answer and then give the learner another chance to respond.[1] Its purpose is to make it clear to the learner what is right, so that the last thing they said or did is the right answer, and reinforcement follows it.[1][2]

Everyone has been on the other side of this. You meet a new coworker and say her name wrong. She doesn't say "no." She says her name, and you say it back. Later that morning you use it by yourself and get it right.[1]

Two adults shake hands across the corner of a table in an office break room, with two coffee mugs beside them: meeting a new coworker.

One error correction, step by step

In our technician lessons, Eli is learning to name pictures. His supervisor changed his plan this week, so "spoon" gets the question alone, with no help. Eli says "sock."[1]

A teacher holds up a picture card of a spoon across the table from a young boy.

Four steps after a wrong answer: no reinforcer and no "no"; model the right answer and praise the copy; a transfer trial without help; mark the first response.

Step What his technician does Why
1. No reinforcer, no "no" No bubbles; her voice stays even For some learners a sharp "no" stings, and they stop trying; for others a big reaction is interesting, and errors come more often
2. Model Says "Spoon." Eli says "Spoon." She says, "That's spoon." The model tells him the answer
3. Transfer trial Card down, card up: "What is it?" with no help. "Spoon" on his own earns praise and bubbles His last response is independent, and the reinforcer follows it
4. Mark Marks a minus: the trial is marked by his first response What came after it was teaching

If he is wrong a second time, his plan has her model the word once more, praise the copy and go on, with no third question. No response within five seconds starts the same steps as a wrong answer.[1]

Two near misses

Two habits can look like Eli's error correction. Either one could be written into another learner's plan; for Eli they're misses, because each differs from what his plan says:[1]

Our Errorless Teaching and Prompting training describes the same choice: some learners do well with "try again" and a second chance, and for others the adult asks them to try again and prompts right away.[2] The plan says which.

Plans differ

Other plans correct errors in other ways. When Owen, who is seven, claps for "Stomp," his technician models stomping, Owen copies, and they go on, with no transfer trial. When Grace, who is twenty-seven, picks up the spatula for the whisk in her training kitchen, her technician points to the whisk, asks about one other tool, and then comes back to it.[1]

Studies that compared error-correction procedures with the same learners found that the procedure that worked best differed from one learner to the next, which is one reason the plan names the steps.[3][4]

Error-correction procedures vary. Some plans repeat the trial, and others model the correct response and then give the learner another chance to respond. The adult follows the learner's plan and, if it is unclear, asks the supervisor. When Eli touches the cat instead of the dog, his plan calls for a model and then the question again: the adult points to the dog and says, "This is the dog," then asks, "Where's the dog?"[1]

When errors keep coming

Error correction is not meant to be used all the time. The goal of teaching is for the learner to earn reinforcement for correct answers, not to be corrected. When a learner makes many errors after prompts have been faded, our training asks the team to look at why: whether the skill was really mastered, whether prompts were faded too fast, or whether the learner has come to depend on prompts.[2] Recording helps here: writing where the errors were ("all three errors on spoon") shows what a percentage can't.[1]

What error correction does not do by itself

It doesn't replace good teaching: if errors keep coming, the team goes back and teaches at whatever level of help the learner needs.[2] And it doesn't make a corrected trial a correct one: on Eli's sheet, a trial corrected to "spoon" is still a minus, because marking it a plus would make his supervisor think the word is nearly learned.[1]

Common questions

Why not just say "no"? For some learners it stings and they stop trying; for others the reaction is interesting. The model already tells the learner the answer.[1]

Should a corrected answer get the same reward? In Eli's plan, no: bubbles are saved for the answer he gives on his own, and the copied answer gets praise.[1]

Who decides how errors are corrected? The learner's supervisor, in the plan. A technician follows the plan's steps and asks if the plan doesn't say.[1]

Related strategies

Discrete trial training · Prompting · Discrimination training · Errorless learning

Learn it with Special Learning

Sources

  1. Special Learning. RBT 3.0, Lesson E-05, "Discrete-trial teaching 2: wrong answers, pacing and recording a block" (forthcoming).
  2. Special Learning. Errorless Teaching and Prompting, webcast, Michele LaMarche.
  3. McGhan, A. C., & Lerman, D. C. (2013). An assessment of error-correction procedures for learners with autism. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 46(3), 626-639. doi:10.1002/jaba.65
  4. Carroll, R. A., Owsiany, J., & Cheatham, J. M. (2018). Using an abbreviated assessment to identify effective error-correction procedures for individual learners during discrete-trial instruction. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 51(3), 482-501. doi:10.1002/jaba.460

All strategies in ABA A to Z